Top 12

After 2 nights of American Idol there will now be 4 more whacked before we get to the Top 12 and turn to 1 eliminated per week.

Top Performers:
Female
Brooke
Carly
Syesha


Male
Michael J.
Jason C.
David C.
David A.

Funny side note
Ryan Seacrest said, "Next, David Archuletta takes on Phil Collins! LIVE!". I was disappointed that David A. was not fighting Phil Collins after the commercial.

Elimination
Male
Luke - He doesn't impress me that much and is really cheesy. His looks may keep him in.
Chikeze - Nothing that exciting.
Wild Cards
Because it gets really tricky I will also keep my wild cards (as there are always outside factors)
David H. - a good way for AI to sweep his fully nude stripping under the rug. He did perform well, but I hate that song with a passion.
Danny O. - He hasn't really impressed me yet and I would actually put him up there to be eliminated, but I think he will get some emo votes, some girl votes, and get the Buck Hollywood votes.

Female
Kady - Pitchy, lack luster, poor song choice, and she kept doing "whistling beaver" s's. You know like the Beavers in cartoons.
Amanda - while she sang well, the thing I have noticed is that all her songs sound the same as though you are listening to one long song.
Wild Card
Kristy Lee - I feel like she will make it with her pseudo-country vibe, but like Simon said, she is forgettable.
Ramiele - She is good, but maybe not as widely loved. I feel she is actually probably safe.